Midwest Insurance Partners
Meet our Team
Our people are the heartbeat of our firm. Our passion for clients is what unites us, drives us and brings out the best in us. Across Midwest Insurance Partners, we create a culture of opportunity for our colleagues — driven by collaboration and innovation.
Owner/CEO
Mitchell Petree
As the owner of Midwest Insurance Partners, I bring over 6 years of experience in the insurance industry, including founding and operating my own Allstate agency, which I started from scratch. This experience provided me with a strong foundation in personal lines insurance, covering everything from golf carts and pets to high-value homes, while mastering my skills in building lasting relationships and understanding clients' unique needs.
​
In addition to my insurance experience, I successfully started and built a property management company from the ground up. This venture deepened my understanding of real estate, client needs, and operational management, allowing me to provide clients with well-rounded insights and support for their insurance and property management needs.
​
At Midwest Insurance Partners, we pride ourselves on delivering exceptional service and fostering trust-based relationships, making us a valued partner in our clients' financial security.
Account Executive
Josh Erd
Josh is an experienced insurance professional, having worked in the industry since 2020. Alongside his career in insurance, he has served as the Area Director for the Fellowship of Christian Athletes (FCA) for over 12 years, where he has had a significant impact on mentoring and inspiring young athletes. His work with FCA reflects his passion for both faith and sports, fostering leadership, character development, and community engagement. With a strong commitment to service, Josh continues to balance his professional and personal endeavors to make a positive difference in the lives of others.
VP of Operations
Shane Gerber
With over 7 years of experience in the insurance industry, I have developed a comprehensive understanding of risk management and client service. My career began at Hylant, then Marsh, and eventually into Owning an Allstate Agency where I honed my skills in account management for commercial clients and analyzing risk exposures for new business clients on both the commercial and personal lines side.
​
I hold a Bachelor’s degree in Accounting and a Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation, equipping me with the expertise to provide insightful guidance in navigating complex insurance landscapes.
​
I am passionate about empowering clients with the knowledge they need to make informed decisions about their coverage options, and I pride myself on building lasting relationships based on trust and transparency.